Golf Balls, TBD 25.5
To paraphrase Shakespeare: What’s in a Ball, A Ball by any other name is still a ball, is it not still round, does it not still fly through the air and roll across the green?
Well, Yes….but no. The better question is What Ball Should YOU Be Playing? Golf balls differ in weight, size, dimple pattern, compression, feel, core and cover material. All factors determining how a ball plays for you based on your swing speed and skill level. A forgiving ball flies nearly the same distance on off center hits, while a premium ball makes you pay dearly in distance if not hit properly. But a premium ball allows a skilled player to shape ball flight at will. Prices can range from $1-$5/ball. So NO, not all balls are alike. Titleist started the revolution in the modern ball in 2000. Their solid core innovation propelled them to top ball manufacturer. Prior to that balls had a liquid core around which was “wound” rubber, think Rubber Bands. Think of the solid core ball as a solid superball with a cover thrown on it. These balls instantly replaced the wound ball due to the massive jump in distance and control players now had.
“Distance” balls are almost always a 2 piece ball, a superball with a plastic covering. These will be your cheapest ball and have an Ionomer or Surylan cover. These balls don’t hold greens as well often rolling out several feet and may seem to bounce off your putter and are generally less durable. Urethane is used on the better balls making them more “sticky” to hold greens and putter control. Increasing the number of layers in the core may help cushion a hard ball to feel softer and/or help with control and spin around the green. Firmness in the middle superball layer is offset by a soft feel with layers around the core. The minimum # of layers for a control ball is 3. Premium balls have 4 layers with urethane cover. Only TaylorMade makes a ball with 5 layers, the TP5 and TP5X. But the more layers a ball has, the more powerful swing is required to compress all those layers and get the best distance and control out of it’s technology.
LPGA Women: 94 mph (Mid swing speed)
Average Scratch Women: 80-90 mph (Low-Mid swing speed)
Women + Seniors + Juniors: 60-80 mph (Low swing speed)
Knowing your swing speed may help you pick a ball. For a rough idea of swing speed, take the total distance of your driver and divide by 2.4. But let’s face it, most of us are in the Low swing speed category and should be playing a low-mid compression ball. How to roughly estimate your swing speed:
Example 1: If I hit my driver a total of 185 yds then 185/2.4=77mph. This is a rough approximation of swing speed. Next time you play, if you have a gps golf watch or range finder, you can get a rough approximation of your driving distance.
Example 2: If I’ve been to a simulator, it will tell me how fast I swing and give me all kinds of data including Carry Distance (travel through the air) and Total Distance (includes roll out). If it tells me I have a swing speed of 65 mph then my expected distance is 65 x 2.4 =156 yds.
Have I totally fried your brain? Are you totally confused? Well here’s a few more details to make your head swim. Balls that used to be hard as a rock 20 yrs ago have gone through a lot of changes, sold to other companies and re-formulated. For instance, Top Flight is no longer a rock, but makes very good cheap balls, although their durability may be a little lacking. Pinnacle is now owned by Titleist and made in the same factory as the PRO V1. I find it to be a very good 2 piece ball of medium compression with decent control around the green and good durability. Pinnacle also makes a “Soft” ball for women in particular, but I haven’t tried them yet. Maxfli was Dunlop, then TaylorMade now owned by Dick’s and makes awesome balls for all levels at a very affordable price. Direct to Consumer balls abound and many, like Vice, are made by engineers that used to be at major golf companies so they know what they are doing! So there’s got to be a ball made for you out there somewhere, you just gotta find it!
A Fun Challenge to test different Balls
Next time you play a round with friends, each of you can bring a different sleeve of balls to test. Play your ball for 6 holes then swap balls. Play the next 6 holes and swap again. This way, you can compare how different balls feel to you and whether a ball gives you more or less distance or if you can hold a green or control it on the putter.
Have a Ball of a Time!
To paraphrase Shakespeare: What’s in a Ball, A Ball by any other name is still a ball, is it not still round, does it not still fly through the air and roll across the green?
Well, Yes….but no. The better question is What Ball Should YOU Be Playing? Golf balls differ in weight, size, dimple pattern, compression, feel, core and cover material. All factors determining how a ball plays for you based on your swing speed and skill level. A forgiving ball flies nearly the same distance on off center hits, while a premium ball makes you pay dearly in distance if not hit properly. But a premium ball allows a skilled player to shape ball flight at will. Prices can range from $1-$5/ball. So NO, not all balls are alike. Titleist started the revolution in the modern ball in 2000. Their solid core innovation propelled them to top ball manufacturer. Prior to that balls had a liquid core around which was “wound” rubber, think Rubber Bands. Think of the solid core ball as a solid superball with a cover thrown on it. These balls instantly replaced the wound ball due to the massive jump in distance and control players now had.
“Distance” balls are almost always a 2 piece ball, a superball with a plastic covering. These will be your cheapest ball and have an Ionomer or Surylan cover. These balls don’t hold greens as well often rolling out several feet and may seem to bounce off your putter and are generally less durable. Urethane is used on the better balls making them more “sticky” to hold greens and putter control. Increasing the number of layers in the core may help cushion a hard ball to feel softer and/or help with control and spin around the green. Firmness in the middle superball layer is offset by a soft feel with layers around the core. The minimum # of layers for a control ball is 3. Premium balls have 4 layers with urethane cover. Only TaylorMade makes a ball with 5 layers, the TP5 and TP5X. But the more layers a ball has, the more powerful swing is required to compress all those layers and get the best distance and control out of it’s technology.
- Swing Speed is how fast the club head travels at the moment of impact. All references to swing speed here are for the driver, the fastest club. The numbers below are for the average of the listed category.
LPGA Women: 94 mph (Mid swing speed)
Average Scratch Women: 80-90 mph (Low-Mid swing speed)
Women + Seniors + Juniors: 60-80 mph (Low swing speed)
Knowing your swing speed may help you pick a ball. For a rough idea of swing speed, take the total distance of your driver and divide by 2.4. But let’s face it, most of us are in the Low swing speed category and should be playing a low-mid compression ball. How to roughly estimate your swing speed:
Example 1: If I hit my driver a total of 185 yds then 185/2.4=77mph. This is a rough approximation of swing speed. Next time you play, if you have a gps golf watch or range finder, you can get a rough approximation of your driving distance.
Example 2: If I’ve been to a simulator, it will tell me how fast I swing and give me all kinds of data including Carry Distance (travel through the air) and Total Distance (includes roll out). If it tells me I have a swing speed of 65 mph then my expected distance is 65 x 2.4 =156 yds.
- Compression Rating is a scale of how much pressure is required to compress the core. The scale goes from 30 to 110, soft to hard respectively. In reality, it is a measurement of deformity of the ball at impact. A harder ball deforms less and has less contact time with the club face. However, there is no industry standard for measuring compression. You cannot compare directly the rating number of one company to another. Use this as a general relative comparison. Some companies just use terms like low, medium and high compression to compare balls. Generally speaking, Low Compression= 30-65, Mid Compression= 70-85 and High Compression= 90-110.
- Ball size: There is a max weight, but not a minimum weight. Heavier balls travel further due to aerodynamics. There is a Diameter minimum, but no maximum. Callaway Supersoft Max is an oversized ball, but does not exceed the weight limit. The size shifts the center of gravity and helps get the ball in the air with slower swing speeds. However, on whole, smaller diameter goes further.
- If you hit your driver over 200yds, want a lot of control around the green, play off a low-mid HCP and don’t mind paying $60/dz ($5/ball) then go with premium balls. If your drive is 160yds or less, there is no reason for you to be playing a premium ball e.g. Pro V1 or TP5. Look for a low compression 2 piece ball. Those in that mid driving range, 160-200yds, will probably find a mid compression ball works best, 2-3 piece ball. The more control you have with pitching and chipping, you may want a Urethane cover too for increased control.
- Finally, Ball manufacturers update their balls every year or two. The ball I loved last year is now a higher compression and no longer fits my game as well! If you loved the 2023 Callaway Supersoft, you may not like the 2025 Supersoft that has also gotten a bit firmer. Other balls softened a bit as the company realized their target golfer for that ball needed less compression. So if you suddenly feel like your ball doesn’t play as well, its not you. Your ball was “updated”!
Have I totally fried your brain? Are you totally confused? Well here’s a few more details to make your head swim. Balls that used to be hard as a rock 20 yrs ago have gone through a lot of changes, sold to other companies and re-formulated. For instance, Top Flight is no longer a rock, but makes very good cheap balls, although their durability may be a little lacking. Pinnacle is now owned by Titleist and made in the same factory as the PRO V1. I find it to be a very good 2 piece ball of medium compression with decent control around the green and good durability. Pinnacle also makes a “Soft” ball for women in particular, but I haven’t tried them yet. Maxfli was Dunlop, then TaylorMade now owned by Dick’s and makes awesome balls for all levels at a very affordable price. Direct to Consumer balls abound and many, like Vice, are made by engineers that used to be at major golf companies so they know what they are doing! So there’s got to be a ball made for you out there somewhere, you just gotta find it!
A Fun Challenge to test different Balls
Next time you play a round with friends, each of you can bring a different sleeve of balls to test. Play your ball for 6 holes then swap balls. Play the next 6 holes and swap again. This way, you can compare how different balls feel to you and whether a ball gives you more or less distance or if you can hold a green or control it on the putter.
Have a Ball of a Time!